How To Do A Lobster Rumble

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

Tasting Table has had a few epic-sounding Lobster Rumbles in New York and Los Angeles and they finally brought it to the Bay.  My food blogger friends Brenda of Bites & Bourbon, Ben of Focus Snap Eat and Sandy of Food Hoe and I were invited and we all jumped at the opportunity.  There were nine participating restaurants including Anchor & Hope, Old Port Lobster Shack, Local Mission Eatery, Waterbar, Farallon, Frank’s Oyster House, Wili’s Seafood & Raw Bar, and Oakland’s own Jack’s Oyster House,  I tasted all of the lobster rolls and had a great time.  Here are some suggestions for the next rumble:

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

Don’t eat lunch

Get there hungry because you need to save room for all those lobster rolls.

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

Get there early

We got there about 15 minutes early and there was already a line, but they were very organized and got us all inside within a few minutes.

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

Start at the end

All of the tables were numbered and set up around the perimeter of the room.  We started at #9 and got through about half the room before we had to stand in any lines.

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

Get some booze

They were serving beer and wine but I was in the mood for a cocktail.  Might as well sip on an Old Fashioned in between lobster rolls, right?

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

Don’t eat all the bread

I got this idea from Ben and it makes sense.  If you don’t fill up on bread, you can save room for more lobster!

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

Save room for dessert

I was so full by the end of the night, but Humphry Slocombe’s Brown Butter ice cream turned out to be a really good last bite.

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

Vote for the one that makes you go mmm

At first I was thinking too much about all the different components and I started to confuse myself.  This one was warm and complex, that one was cool and simple, but which one was BETTER?

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

At the end of the night, I just voted for the only lobster roll that made me go mmmmm, and that was Anchor & Hope’s.  It had the perfect ratio of lobster to bread, which was toasted.  The lobster was dressed very simply with lemon and lobster roe salt.  And most importantly, when I took a bite, I involuntarily murmured “mmmm…”

photo: Christina Mitchell

photo: Christina Mitchell

Congratulations to Old Port Lobster Shack, who ended up winning.  Their lobster roll was also really tasty and I would love to visit the restaurant one day.  All in all, we had a great time and a portion of the proceeds went to Share Our Strength, so it was for a good cause.

Christina Mitchell

Christina Mitchell

Christina is the founder of East Bay Dish. Her writing has also been featured in East Bay Express, Berkeleyside, Oakland Magazine and Edible East Bay.
Christina Mitchell

Latest posts by Christina Mitchell (see all)